Welcome to Carmela's Pizza Restaurant
At Carmela's Pizza Restaurant, we celebrate the art of pizza-making while offering a diverse menu that delights every palate. Nestled in Montgomery, NY, our eatery is more than just a place to dine; it's where tradition meets innovation. We pride ourselves on our cozy atmosphere, perfect for families and groups alike. Our offerings range from savory pizzas and juicy burgers to fresh seafood, all crafted with care and quality ingredients. Whether you're enjoying a meal outdoors or indulging in our renowned wings and crispy mozzarella sticks, every bite promises satisfaction. Join us for lunch or dinner, and experience the warmth of Carmela’s!
Carmela's Pizza Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
No one else cooks like Carmelas. Authentic Food, great service and completely renovated. Its really busy but everything came out on time. Good menu and even better food
So grateful Carmelas is open, we are regulars there and love the atmosphere, food and staff. The newly remodeled restaurant is very pleasant and bright which is much nicer. Our favorite is the cauliflower pizza which has yet to ...
Been coming weekly for almost a year now. Never had a bad experience and the food is consistently good. The waitresses even know my orders yes I change it up often by heart. Never have to wait long for a beer either.
First time going since the renovation. Food was great and my family was happy with their meals. The service and atmosphere needs work. I understand it takes time and business cant always win every customer over all the time. I bring it up ...
Quick service n grrat food selection. The salad is had was very well presented n quite tasty. My wife had linguine and she raved about it
The Caesars salad was perfect as was the Margarita pizza.
What an amazing time! Our server Morgan was amazing! She is so personable and soo fast!! The food was incredible and the owners are the best!! Highly recommend!!
My wife and I love Carmelas for date night. Large menu. Fantastic dinners. The chef does an amazing job with the sauces for all dishes. We also order pizza and drive past many other places to get from Carmelas. Great friendly service. ...
Location
-
1021 State Route 17K Montgomery, NY 12549 United States Hotline: (845) 457-3021
Welcome to Carmela's Pizza Restaurant, where every meal is a celebration of flavor and togetherness. Nestled in the charming town of Montgomery, NY, on State Route 17K, this restaurant invites you to explore a delightful fusion of pizza, burgers, and seafood. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting slice or a gourmet seafood dish, Carmela's has something to satisfy every palate.
The atmosphere at Carmela's is casual yet inviting, making it an ideal spot for lunch, dinner, or special occasions. With amenities such as outdoor seating, private dining options, and a kid-friendly environment, this restaurant is perfect for families and groups alike. Plus, it’s wheelchair accessible, ensuring everyone can enjoy a great meal.
- Reservations: Yes
- Delivery: Available
- Takeout: Available
- Outdoor Seating: Yes, with heated options
- Credit Cards: Accepted (including Cryptocurrency)
- Free Wi-Fi: Available
The menu boasts an impressive range of dishes, each crafted with care. The Cheese Ravioli Parmigiana ($14.95) arrives perfectly cooked, enveloped in a rich marinara that clings lovingly to every pasta pocket. If you're in the mood for something heartier, the Baked Ziti ($13.95) is a crowd-pleaser, with its melting cheese topping and a savory sauce that will have you coming back for more.
Carmela's doesn't stop at pasta. The Chicken Piccata ($16.95) is a standout, featuring tender chicken sautéed with capers in a bright white wine sauce that elevates the dish. For a richer flavor, try the Chicken Marsala ($16.95); this option tantalizes the taste buds with its luscious mushroom and Marsala wine combination over perfectly al dente pasta.
Seafood lovers will appreciate the Shrimp Scampi ($17.95), where succulent shrimp are tossed with garlic, lemon, and butter for a dish that sings with seaside freshness. Alternatively, the Shrimp Parmigiana over pasta ($19.95) offers a delectable twist on a classic that’s sure to leave an imprint on your culinary memory.
In addition to the fantastic food, Carmela's offers a lively atmosphere with moderate noise, making it an ideal backdrop for enjoying a meal with friends or family. With waiter service and an extensive beverage list featuring beer and wine, every dining experience here is enhanced. Don’t forget to ask about their catering options if you’re planning a larger gathering!
To sum up, Carmela's Pizza Restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it’s a community hub where flavors unite, and memories are made. Whether you’re stopping by for a casual day meal or settling in for a comforting evening, the warmth of this restaurant will surely linger long after the last bite. The phone number to make your reservation or order your meal is (845) 457-3021. Come and enjoy a culinary journey that promises satisfaction with every dish!
